From the Risale-i Nur Collection 2

Letters

Contents

THE FIRST LETTER: The answers to four questions:

The First is a convincing answer to a question about Hazrat Khidr's life, and in connection with it explains the five levels of life.

The Second explains how, in accordance with certain Qur'anic verses, death is created and a bounty, like life.

The Third: A most reasonable explanation of where Hell is situated, of the Greater and Lesser Hells. It points out in reasoned manner the wisdom in the creation of the Greater Hell, and how in majestic fashion, manifesting Divine favour and wrath, Heaven and Hell are the two fruits of the tree of the universe and will be filled with the produce of this world.

The Fourth: This shows that like metaphorical love for individuals may be transformed into true love, so too, through belief in God, metaphorical love for this world may be transformed into true love, which is acceptable.

THE SECOND LETTER: Six reasons why, in accordance with Qur'anic verses, those working for the cause of religion should practice self-sufficiency, and if there is no compelling reason to do so, not accept alms and gifts.

THE THIRD LETTER: A description of two verses which in miraculous fashion allude to the face of the heavens and orderly motion of the heavenly bodies. It includes Two Points, the First explaining how the wicked will travel to Hell, the Second showing the infinite ease in Unity and infinite difficulty in multiplicity.

THE FOURTH LETTER: This makes two points about the Risale-i Nur and its way: firstly, that it manifests the meaning of the verse, He who has been given wisdom......; and secondly, about 'the way of impotence'. Finally is a piece "resembling poetry" on the Utterance of the Stars.

THE FIFTH LETTER: Written in the face of the tendency of some people to attach too much importance to Sufism at the expense of serving the cause of spreading the truths of belief, this letter points out the three sorts of sainthood and that the way of 'greater sainthood' is following the Practices of the Prophet (PBUH) and direct service to the truths of belief at this time. It states that the unfolding of the truths of belief is the most important aim of the Sufi ways, and that this is also possible through the Risale-i Nur, but in a shorter time.

THE SIXTH LETTER: This explains the meaning of two verses concerning reliance on God, and describes a light and consolation proceeding from them and belief which dispelled the darkness of five grievous degrees of exile.

THE SEVENTH LETTER: A decisive answer to atheists at the present time who seek to criticize the Prophet Muhammed's (PBUH) number of wives and his marriage with Zaynab in particular, pointing out some important instances of wisdom in his marriages.

THE EIGHTH LETTER: In accordance with the verse, God is the Best of Protectors and He is the Most Merciful of the. Merciful, this shows that what the Prophet Jacob (Upon whom be peace} felt for Joseph (Upon whom be peace), was not love of a passionate kind, but compassion - compassion being more elevated and pure, and the means of attaining to the Divine Names of Merciful and Compassionate.

THE NINTH LETTER: A discussion of wonder-working (kerāmet), Divine bestowal, and Divine favour which points out that although it is harmful to display wonderworking, it is a form of thanks to make known Divine bestowal, since it is a bounty. Secondly is an explanation of how intense emotions such as curiosity, love, greed, ambition, and stubbornness are of two sorts metaphorical and real. Having been given in order to gain the matters of the Hereafter, while the former sort are the source of bad morals, the latter are beneficial and the source of good morals. Thirdly is a discussion on the differences between 'Islam' and 'belief' (Iman)

THE TENTH LETTER: This consists of the answers to two questions. The First explains the realities of the 'Clear Book' and the 'Clear Record', mentioned in several places in the Qur'an. While the Second is a convincing explanation of where the Great Gathering and Last Judgement will take place.

THE ELEVENTH LETTER: Four Topics. Expounding the verse, Indeed the wiles of Satan are weak, the First is a cure for those who suffer from scruples. The Second is included in the Seventeenth Word, and not repeated here. The Third and Fourth are two examples demonstrating the impotence of modern civilization before the Qur'an. The examples show how the Qur'anic decrees on women's inheritence are both pure justice and pure compassion.

THE TWELFTH LETTER: The brief replies to three questions disputed over by some people with a modern educational background.

The First is a decisive answer to why Adam was expelled from Paradise and why some of his descendants are sent to Hell

The Second explains why the creation of evil is not evil, and why Divine Mercy permits it.

The Third explains why calamities and tribulations being inflicted on even the innocent and animals is not tyrannical or contrary to justice.

THE THIRTEENTH LETTER: The reply, written in the tongue of the Old Said, to frequent questions as to how Bediuzzaman endured the oppression inflicted on him by the politicians and 'the worldly'. It shows how the varieties of ill-treatment were transformed by Divine Mercy into various sorts of mercy. It also gives the reasons Bediuzzaman did not apply for his release papers, and in addition for his total indifference towards politics.

THE FOURTEENTH LETTER: was not written.

THE FIFTEENTH LETTER: Six important answers to six important questions:

The First: The answer in 'Two Stations' to the questions why the Companions of the Prophet (PBUH) did not perceive the troublemakers with the eye of sainthood, so that it resulted in three of the Four Rightly Guided Caliphs being martyred. For it is said the Companions were greater than the saints.

The Second: What was the true nature of the wars that started in Ali's (RA} time? How should those who took part in them be described?

The Third: A most important answer concerning the wisdom in the cruel treatment received by members of the Prophet's Family.

The Fourth: It says in narrations that after Jesus (UWP) kills the Dajjal at the end of time, most people will enter the true religion, however others state that no one will remain who says, Allah! Allah! A convincing answer to this.

The Fifth: An explanation of the question: Will the immortal spirits be grieved by the events of the Last Day?

The Sixth: A satisfying answer to the question, Does the verse, Everything will perish save His countenance include the Hereafter and Paradise and Hell?

THE SIXTEENTH LETTER: This consists of Five Points:

First Point explains that service of the Qur'an forbad Bediuzzaman from any involvement in politics, which at that time consisted mostly of falsehood, innovation, and misguidance.

Second Point: Service to the Qur'an and working seriously for the Hereafter necessitated his aloofness from politics; it therefore was not a case of his looking tolerantly on the errors and activities of the politicians, he did not concern himself with them at all.

Third Point: This relates two stories illustrating an important reason for Bediuzzaman enduring the severe oppression to which he was subject.

Fourth Point: The answer to a number of suspicious questions put to him by 'the worldly'. It describes some undeniable instances of Divine favours connected with his service to the Qur'an.

Fifth Point: A reply which reduces to silence those who were unjustly proposing certain of their 'principles' and innovations to Bediuzzaman.

ADDENDUM TO THE SIXTEENTH LETTER: Written to dispel the groundless fears and suspicions of the authorities and atheists concerning Bediuzzaman, despite his having completely withdrawn from the world and politics; also written to preserve the dignity of learning.

THE SEVENTEENTH LETTER: A letter of condolence on the death of a child. Although it is short and addressed to a close student of Bediuzzaman, it is of considerable general benefit. It establishes that, as the Qur'an teaches, children who die before the age of puberty remain as children in the Everlasting Realm, and are returned to the embrace of their parents.

THE EIGHTEENTH LETTER: This consists of Three Important Matters.

The First explains and illustrates by means of a comparison how sometimes the things the saints witness and have unfolded to them through illumination in other worlds and levels of existence appear contrary to reality in this Manifest World.

The Second: A clear explanation of the way of the Unity of Existence, which has been the cause of confusion and controversy. It proves that the way of the Companions of the Prophet (PBUH) and the veracious, the people of sobriety, is sounder and more elevated and acceptable.

An Addendum to the Second Matter

The Third: A brief indication the solution of one of the three main riddles of creation. These have been solved completely in the Twenty-Ninth and Thirtieth Words, and this third one, in the Twenty-Fourth Letter.

THE NINETEENTH LETTER, The Miracles of Muhammed (PBUH): Itself a marvel in several respects, this Letter describes more; than three hundred miracles of Muhammed (PBUH). It consists of Nineteen Signs.

The First Sign establishes that the Master and Owner of the Universe will speak with man, and foremost the most perfect of mankind, with Muhammed (PBUH), and make him the guide to the rest of humanity.

Second Sign: On the prophethood of Muhammed.

Third Sign: The evidences for Muhammed's Prophethood.

Fourth Sign: Comprises Six Principles to ensure a complete understanding of the subject of the Noble Prophet's predictions concerning his Companions, his Family, and his Community.

Fifth Sign: Examples of Hadiths concerning the Prophet's predictions relating to the Unseen. It includes important answers to the questions of why Ali did not precede the others in holding the Caliphate, and why Islam experienced such disorders during his Caliphate; why the Caliphate did not remain in his Family; and the reasons for the dissensions at that time.

Sixth Sign: Consists of further predictions of future events, and includes the answer to a question about the Shi'a's love for Ali.

Seventh Sign: Sixteen examples relating to the Prophet's (PBUH) effecting increase in food.

Eighth Sign: Relates miracles which were manifested in connection with water.

Ninth Sign: Examples of miracles related to trees: Like human beings, trees obeyed his orders, and moving from their places, came to him.

Tenth Sign: The miracle of the Moaning of the Pole.

Eleventh Sign: Shows how rocks and mountains from among lifeless creatures demonstrated prophetic miracles.

Twelfth Sign: Consists of three examples related to the Eleventh Sign, but which are of great importance.

Thirteenth Sign: Examples of the Noble Prophet's healing the sick and the wounded.

Fourteenth Sign: This describes wonders manifested as a result of his prayers.

Fifteenth Sign: Consists of Three Branches:

The First shows how the animal kingdom recognized the Prophet (PBUH) and displayed his miracles.

The Second concerns corpses, jinns, and angels recognizing the Noble Prophet.

The Third is the protection and preservation of the Noble Prophet, of which there were many instances, and which were clear miracles.

Sixteenth Sign: Describes the wonders that took place before his prophetic mission, but which were related to it, called irhasat. They were of three kinds:

The First Kind: The tidings of Muhammed's Prophethood given by the Torah, the Bible, the Psalms of David, and other scriptures.

The Second Kind: Tidings of his coming given by soothsayers, and people known at that time as saints and gnostics

The Third Kind: The wondrous events that occurred at the time of, and in conjunction with, the birth of the Noble Prophet (PBUH).

Seventeenth Sign: The Prophet's own self.

Eighteenth Sign: The greatest miracle of the Noble Prophet, the All-Wise Qur'an. It consists of Three Points describing aspects of the Qur'an's miraculousness.

Nineteenth Sign: Fifteen Principles indicating the integrity, truthfulness, and veracity of the Noble Prophet (PBUH), the most brilliant and conclusive proof of Divine Unity and eternal happiness.

FIRST ADDENDUM TO THE MIRACLES OF MUHAMMED: The Nineteenth Word, it proves decisively and explains the Prophethood of Muhammed, silencing even the most obdurate opponents.

SECOND ADDENDUM: About the Miracle of the Splitting of the Moon. Refuting objections made to the miracle in the name of science, it demonstrates that there was nothing to prevent its occurrence, and proves clearly that it happened.

THIRD ADDENDUM: About the Prophethood of Muhammed (PBUH), this is a concise index-like answer to the question in the Treatise on the Ascension: "Why was this mighty Ascension particular to Muhammed the Arabian (Upon whom be blessings and peace)?"

FOURTH ADDENDUM: The Sixteenth Degree, on the Prophethood of Muhammed, from the Supreme Sign.

THE TWENTIETH LETTER: This contains Two Stations and an Introduction, and expounds the verse, So know there is no god but God, and the eleven phrases of the Hadith: There is no god but God, He is One, He has no partner etc. The First Station points out the good news for man that each phrase contains, and the Second demonstrates with powerful proofs the degrees of the true affirmation Divine Unity.

ADDENDUM TO THE TENTH PHRASE OF THE TWENTIETH LETTER: That is: And He is Powerful over all things. It points out through three comparisons that when everything is attributed to Divine Power, they become as simple as one thing, and if they are not and are ascribed to things other than Him, each thing becomes as difficult as all things.

THE TWENTY-FIRST LETTER: A short but important letter showing how on five levels the verse, Whether one or both of them attain old age in your life.... summons children to be kindly to their parents.

THE TWENTY-SECOND LETTER: In accordance with a number of Qur'anic verses, the First Topic summons believers to love and brotherhood. It points out effective ways of preventing discord, rancour, and enmity, and proves that they are extremely damaging both from the point of view of truth, wisdom, humanity, and Islam, and for personal, social, and spiritual life, and are to be rejected.

The Second Topic points out effective way of avoiding greed, another awesome disease, as harmful for the life of Islam as enmity. It also explains the importance of zakat and the wisdom in this pillar of Islam.

Conclusion showing how the Qur'an reproaches the backbiter on six levels with the verse, Would anv among you like to eat the flesh of his dead brother?

THE TWENTY-THIRD LETTER: The answers to seven questions:

The First: What is the best way believers can pray for one another?

The Second: Is it appropriate to use the phrase May God be pleased with him for those other than the Companions?

The Third: Which wore superior, the great interpreters of the Holy Law, or the 'Shahs' of the true Sufi paths?

The Fourth: What is the purpose of the verse, God is with those who patiently persevere?

The Fifth: How did the Prophet (PBUH) worship before his prophetic mission?

The Sixth: What was the wisdom in his prophethood commencing when he was forty years of age?

The Seventh: Is the following a Hadith: "The best of your youths are those who resemble men of mature age...."

The letter concludes with a subtle point about Joseph's (Upon whom be peace} elevated veracity, inspired by the verse, Take my soul at death as one submitting to Your will.

THE TWENTY-FOURTH LETTER: This consists of Two Stations which solve one of the most obscure riddles of the universe, and form an answer to the question: How can the Divine Names of All-Compassionate, Wise, and Loving be reconciled with death, separation, calamity, and suffering? The First Station consists of Five Signs which show the necessitating cause and reason, the Second Station, Five Indications, which point out the aims and benefits.

FIRST ADDENDUM TO THE TWENTY-FOURTH LETTER: In Five Points, this expounds important aspects of the verse, No importance would your Sustainer attach to you, were it not for your supplication.

SECOND ADDENDUM: A most convincing, reasoned answer, in Five Points, to three important questions about the Ascension of the Prophet Muhammed (PBUH) and the 'Mevlid'. The Conclusion shows that the most perfect individual and the universal master of the cosmos is the Noble Prophet (PBUH).

THE TWENTY-FIFTH LETTER: This was to consist of Twenty-Five Points about Sura Ya Sin, but was not realized.

THE TWENTY-SIXTH LETTER: Consists of Four Topics.

First Topic: 'A Proof of the Qur'an Against Satan and His Party', this defeats in argument the Devil and his followers by refuting clearly one of their cunning stratagems, which is to be 'unbiased'; that is, their deceiving people into considering the Qur'an and matters of religion 'impartially'.

Second Topic: This explains how a person may have numerous personalities in respect of his different duties, and describes the three personalities of the author.

Third Topic: In Seven Matters, this expounds the verse, We....... made you into nations and tribes, that you may know each other, pointing out significant truths about social relations and mankind being created as different peoples and groups. A most beneficial remedy for nationalism, the most awesome disease of this time, it also exposes the pseudo-patriots and their fraudulent attitudes.

Fourth Topic: Consists of Ten unrelated Matters, which are the answers to six questions.

First Matter: Explains several subtle points of the Qur'an connected with 'the worlds' in the phrase Sustainer of All the Worlds, their being eighteen thousand.

Second Matter: Explains an important aspect of knowledge of God in discussing what Muhyiddin al-Arabi meant by saying to Fakhruddin Razi: "To know God is different to knowing He exists."

Third Matter: How is the verse, We have honoured the sons of Adam, conformable with the verse, He was indeed unjust and foolish?

Fourth Matter: A brilliant reply to a question about the wisdom contained in the Hadith: "Renew your belief means of 'There is no god but God'"

Fifth Matter: Will one who says There is no god but God,but does not say, Muhammed is the Prophet of God be saved?

Sixth Matter: By means of a comparison, this drives Satan and his party into a corner and takes possession of the field in the name of the Qur'an, thus showing all the Prophet's qualities and conduct to be miraculous and proving his prophethood.

Seventh Matter: Seven brief examples of people who for various reasons ceased their service to the Qur'an and received blows contrary to their intentions, written to strengthen their morale and dispel their groundless fear

Eighth Matter: An important answer to those who want to translate the words of the Qur'an and various supplications into other languages, showing that the words of the Qur'an and glorifications of the Prophet {PBUH} are not lifeless garments for the meanings; they are like living skin. Garments are changed, but it would be harmful to the body if the skin were to be changed.

Ninth Matter: An important answer to the question, "Can there be saints outside the Ahl-i Sunna wa'l-Jama'at, who are the people of truth.

Tenth Matter: An important principle for those wishing to see and visit Bediuzzaman.

THE TWENTY-SEVENTH LETTER: Consists of letters written by the author of the Risale-i Nur to his students, as well as some written by the Risale-i Nur students to their Master, and to each other. Since it is three or four times the size of the present collection, it has not been included here, but published separately under the titles of Barla Letters, Kastamonu Letters, and Emirda? Letters.

THE TWENTY-EIGHTH LETTER: This consists of Eight Matters.

First Matter: Seven Points explaining the reality and benefits of true dreams.

Second Matter: This was written to put a stop to and solve an argument about the Hadith which describes how Moses (Upon whom be peace) struck Azrail (Upon whom be peace) in the eye, and is a satisfying answer to objections of this sort levelled at Hadiths by the people of misguidance.

Third Matter: Five Points stating that those who visit Bediuzzaman should do so only in respect of his being herald of the Qur'an, not with any other intention. It mentions too a number of examples of the Divine favours associated with service of the Qur'an that Bediuzzaman and his students had received. A supplement to it enumerates some Divine favours in the writing of the Words.

Fourth Matter: Four Points written in the tongue of the Old Said, in reply to questions about the small mosque Bediuzzaman used being unlawfully raided on a number of occasions, and subsequently closed.

Fifth Matter: On Thanks; this expounds most convincingly the many Qur'anic commands to offer thanks. It demonstrates that the universe is a treasury with thanks being the key; and that sustenance is its result and the introduction to thanks.

Sixth Matter: This was not included here, as it was to be included in another collection.

Seventh Matter: This consists of Seven Signs describing seven instances of Divine favour connected with the Risale-i Nur and those who serve it. These are preceded by Seven Reasons for making known the seven Divine favours.

Answer to a Confidential Question: explains the power and effectiveness of the Risale-i Nur.

Conclusion to the Seventh Matter: describes a further Divine favour in the form of the 'coincidences' (tawafuqat).

Eighth Matter: This consists of Eight Points, which form the answers to six questions:

First Point: concerns the signs of the Unseen in the form of 'coincidences' being found in all the parts of the Risale-i Nur.

Second and Third Points were not included.

Fourth Point: Consists of answers to six questions about the Last Judgement and Great Gathering.

Fifth Point: In the period between prophets, did the forefathers of the Noble Prophet (PBUH) belong to a religion and were they religious?

Sixth Point: Were there any prophets among the Prophet's (PBUH) forefathers?

Seventh Point: Which of the narrations about the belief of the Prophet's parents and his grandfather are the most authentic?

Eighth Point: What is the authentic narration concerning his uncle, Abu Talib?

THE TWENTY-NINTH LETTER: This consists of Nine Sections, and contains twenty-nine important points.

First Section: is Nine Points.

First Point: An answer to those who say, "The Qur'an's mysteries are not known; the commentators have not understood its realities."

Second Point: Explains an instance of wisdom in the Qur'anic oaths, such as, By the sun and its glorious splendour.

Third Point is about the 'disjointed letters', which are a Divine cypher, at the start of a number of Suras.

Fourth Point points out a flash of the Qur'an's miraculousness in its style, showing that a true translation of it is not possible.

Fifth Point demonstrates that it is impossible to translate the phrase All praise to be God, that its means can be expressed only in a few lines.

Sixth Point: An important explanation for the use of the first person plural in You alone do we worship and, from You alone do we seek help.

Seventh Point: Expounding, Guide us to the Straight Path, it points out the harm of innovations.

Eighth Point: Explains a point about 'the marks of Islam' being 'general rights.'

Ninth Point: In connection with the call to prayer, this explains how the matters of the Shari'a are of two kinds.

Second Section: On the Month of Ramadan. Nine Points explaining nine instances of wisdom in the fast of Ramadan, expounding the verse, It was the Month of Ramadan in which the Qur'an was revealed.

Third Section: Concerns the writing of a Qur'an showing, the 'coinciding' of the word Allah. Consisting of Nine Matters, only the first was included here.

Fourth Section, also about 'coincidences,' it consists of Three Points, the Four Points of the Third being included here .

Fifth Section: One beautiful light of the many mysteries of the verse, God is the Light of the heavens and earth. This treatise is short, yet important.

Sixth Section: Written to warn students and servants of the Qur'an, so that they should not be deceived by six of the stratagems of satanic individuals and dissemblers.

First Stratagem: Exposes their attempts to attract people through desire for rank and position.

Second Stratagem: Points out how they take advantage of the vein of fear.

Third Stratagem: They hunt many people through greed and ambition, in order to make them give up service to the Qur'an.

Fourth Stratagem: They excite nationalist feelings, in order to create discord and make Bediuzzaman's students lose their love of him.

Fifth Stratagem: They encourage egotism, man's weakest vein

Sixth Stratagem: They take advantage of the human characteristics of laziness, the desire for physical comfort, and attachment to other duties.

A Sacred Date: The date a mystery of the Qur'an became clear.

Addendum to the Sixth Section: Six Questions: Written in order to avoid the disgust that will be levelled at us in the future. A petition with which to hit over the head the followers of modern low civilization, which this century have a hundred thousand times over necessitated the existence of Hell, and to silence those who have deviated from the true path

Seventh Section: Seven Signs formed of seven powerful and decisive answers to seven questions, which also expound the two verses:

First Sign: A firm answer to those people of innovation who claim that it is permissible to translate the call to prayer into other languages because certain people who have embraced Islam do so in Europe

Second Sign: A decisive answer to those who say that in Europe, a revolution was brought about in the Catholic Church by reformists and philosophers, then they progressed; why should there not be such a religious revolution in Islam?

Third Sign: They also say: Religious bigotry made us backward. Europe advanced on giving up bigotry, so would it not be better if we did too?

Fourth Sign: The firm a answer to a deceptive and misleading question put by those who purport to want to strengthen religion by means of nationalism.

Fifth Sign: A powerful answer to u question as to how the Mehdi will be able to put the world to rights in a few years, when like at the present time, society has grown so corrupt and religious feeling has waned.

Sixth Sign: About the Mehdi routing the secret society of the Sufyan at the end of time, and Jesus (Upon whom be peace) defeating the Dajjal and following the Shari' a of Islam.

Seventh Sign: The answer to a question as to why, having opened up a completely new way, Bediuzzaman had changed the manner of the Old Said and was striking philosophy at the very roots, and that the principles known as the physical sciences were very superficial beside the Qur'an.

Eighth Section: The Eight Symbols. These eight short treatises on 'coincidences' (tawafuqat) have been included in another collection, and not included here.

Ninth Section: The Nine Allusions. Nine Allusions about the ways of sainthood and Sufism:

First Allusion: A definition of the Sufi path, and explanation of the truth underlying the terms Sufism, path, sainthood, and spiritual journeying.

Second Allusion: Explains how the heart is 'worked' through reflective thought and remembrance of God, and how this is a means to happiness.

Third Allusion: Explains how sainthood is a proof of prophethood, and the Sufi way, a proof of the Shari'a.

Fourth Allusion: The way of sainthood is both very easy and very difficult; and very long and very short; and it is both valuable, and dangerous. This explains also the two ways of 'innerjourneying' and 'outerjourneying'.

Fifth Allusion: Explains the reality of the Unity of Existence and the Unity of Witnessing, and establishes the superiority of the people of 'the legacy of prophethood'.

Sixth Allusion: Three Points showing that the best of the ways of sainthood is following the Practices of the Prophet (PBUH), and its most important foundation, sincerity; and that this world is the realm of wisdom and service, not reward; so spiritual pleasures and illuminations should not be sought here.

Seventh Allusion: Four Points pointing out that the Sufi way should serve the Shari'a; that its highest degrees are matters of the Shari'a; that it should always remain as a means and follow the Shari'a; and an answer to the question: Can saints be found outside the bounds of the Sunna and Shari' a?

Eighth Allusion: Describes Eight Abysses on the Sufi way

Ninth Allusion: Nine of the sweet fruits of the Sufi way

ADDENDUM: A short, safe, and direct way leading to Almighty God, taken from the Qur'an

THE THIRTIETH LETTER: The Arabic Qur'anic commentary, Signs of Miraculousness (Isharat al-I'jaz).

THE THIRTY-FIRST LETTER: The Thirty-One Flashes.

THE THIRTY-SECOND LETTER: The treatise in free verse called Leme'at. It is also the Thirty-Second Flash and has been included at the end of The Words.

THE THIRTY-THIRD LETTER: Thirty-Three Windows making known the Creator. Since in one respect it is the Thirty-Third Word, it has been included in The Words and not repeated here.

SEEDS OF REALITY: Aphorisms compiled from a number of Bediuzzaman's early works, which were first published in 1920.

* * *